Author: rolland.diers@gmail.com

  • How to Audit a Stock-Picking Newsletter: Log vs. Tips

    How to Audit a Stock-Picking Newsletter: Log vs. Tips

    Most stock-picking newsletters ask you to trust the record. Very few let you audit it. That difference is not rhetorical – it is structural, and you can see it in about ten minutes if you know which columns to read.

    This is a side-by-side audit: a tip-driven newsletter on one side, a disclosing committee log on the other. The standard is the audit, not the pitch. What follows is what each side publishes, what each side hides, and what you can actually verify before money moves.

    Two ledgers, two standards

    A newsletter sells you an outcome. A committee log sells you a record.

    The newsletter’s front page carries a performance figure, a handful of wins, and a name. The log carries dated entries: what was bought, what was sold, what was rejected, who dissented, and what the position looked like as of a stated date. One is a summary of a story. The other is a column you can rule and check.

    You are not comparing two marketing styles. You are comparing two different answers to the same question: if this went wrong, what would I be able to see?

    What a tip-driven newsletter publishes

    Tip products publish selectively. That is the design, not an accident.

    Typically you get a headline return with no start date, or a start date chosen after the fact. You get the closed winners and a vague reference to positions that “did not work out.” You get a call-to-action before you get a method. You may get an archived issue, but rarely a fill – an actual execution with a date, a price, and a size.

    Ask three questions and watch how quickly the record thins:

    • What is the as-of date on that return?
    • Where are the positions you closed at a loss, on the same schedule as the wins?
    • What did you hold last quarter, and at what size?

    A newsletter can answer all three honestly. Most choose not to, because the honest answer is unaudited and therefore inconvenient.

    What a disclosing committee log publishes

    A committee log is built to survive exactly those questions.

    Every decision carries a date. Every fill carries a price and a size. Dissent is recorded, not smoothed over – when one member votes against a position, that vote stays in the record. Losses appear on the same cadence as wins, with the same formatting, in the same column. When the committee is wrong, the entry says so.

    The public log is the floor, not the ceiling. Anything a member sees behind the login – current positions, the full decision history, the cross-account view – is an extension of the same document, not a different story told to a different audience.

    That is what makes it auditable. Not the numbers. The structure that produces them.

    The audit: seven things you can verify

    Run this against any product, newsletter or committee, and score what you find.

    1. As-of dating. Is every performance figure stamped with the date it was measured? “Since inception” without a date is decoration.
    2. Losses on schedule. Are the losers published when they happen, or in a footnote a year later?
    3. Fills, not intentions. Can you see an execution – date, price, size – rather than a call you were told to make?
    4. Dissent retained. When the committee split, does the record show it, or only the outcome?
    5. Positions at a point in time. Can you reconstruct what was held on a given date, not just what is held today?
    6. A method you can read. Is there a stated process you could follow yourself, or only a personality you are asked to follow?
    7. One record, no audience split. Does the free view and the paid view agree, or does the paid tier get a cleaner story?

    A newsletter can pass this audit. The point is that most cannot, and that you can tell within an afternoon – before you pay for a year of someone else’s confidence.

    Where tips fail the audit

    Tips fail on the two hardest columns: the timing of losses and the retention of dissent.

    A tip is a claim about the future with no dated past attached. Add one loss published on schedule and the whole tone changes. Add a recorded dissent and the guru becomes a committee. Most products are not structured to do either, so they compete on conviction instead of disclosure – which is exactly the trade the sceptical reader should refuse.

    Process versus tips is not a matter of taste. It is a matter of what is left on the page after the marketing is removed.

    What verifiable actually costs

    Transparency is not free. Publishing losses on the same cadence as wins means your record looks worse than a curated one, at least at a glance. It means as-of dates that will eventually be unflattering. It means leaving the dissent in.

    That cost is the signal. A record designed to be checked is a record that has already accepted being wrong in public. You are not looking for a product that has never lost. You are looking for one whose losses are already sitting there, dated, next to the wins.

    How to run this on anything you are considering

    Pick the oldest claim on the page. Find its as-of date. Then look for the matching loss. If you cannot find both within ten minutes, you have your answer.

    Do that for the newsletter. Then do it for the log. The comparison is structural, and it holds up without a single number being quoted back at you.


    Diers Capital publishes its public log of every vote, dissent and fill free of charge. Membership adds the logged-in view: current positions, the full decisions history and the cross-account picture. Nothing here is investment advice, and no performance figure should be read as a promise of future results.

  • What Is a Trading Decision Log – and What It Should Show

    What Is a Trading Decision Log – and What It Should Show

    A trading decision log is a dated, permanent record of what a strategy did and why – every vote, every dissent, every fill – written down when the decision was made, not when the result was known. It is the difference between a track record and a story about a track record.

    If you audit before you trust, the decision log is the first artifact you should ask to see. Not the returns page. Not the case study. The log.

    What a decision log actually is

    A decision log is a ledger. Each line records one decision and the conditions under it:

    • What the committee considered.
    • Who voted, and which way.
    • Who dissented, and on what grounds.
    • What was bought or sold, in what size, at what price.
    • The date stamp – as-of when the entry was written.

    That last one does the heavy lifting. Every entry carries an as-of date, so you can tell whether it was written before the move or after it. A log without timestamps is a memory. A log with them is evidence.

    What a decision log is not

    It is not a newsletter. A newsletter tells you what someone thinks now. A log tells you what someone decided then, and holds them to it.

    It is not a returns chart. A chart is a summary – useful, but it collapses hundreds of decisions into a single line and hides every one of them. The log keeps the decisions intact.

    It is not a marketing document. If a log flatters the strategy, it is not a log. It is a brochure with dates on it.

    The five entries every log should show you

    Read any decision log against this list. If a category is missing, ask why.

    1. The vote

    Who decided, and by what margin. A strategy run by one person has a vote of one, and that is fine – so long as it is stated. What you are looking for is a decision that can be attributed, not an anonymous “we.”

    2. The dissent

    The minority view, published. This is the entry most logs skip, and the one that tells you the most. A record with no dissent anywhere is not a record of a committee. It is a record of a monologue. Dissent is where a strategy shows its reasoning under pressure rather than its consensus after the fact.

    3. The fill

    The actual execution: instrument, direction, size, price. A decision without a fill is an opinion. The fill is what ties the intention to the market, and it is the line that lets you reconstruct what the strategy did on any given day.

    4. The as-of date

    When the entry was written. Not when it was published. Not when the position closed. The as-of date is the single most falsifiable field in the whole document, and it is the first thing a serious reader checks.

    5. The losses

    Published on the same schedule as the wins. Same format, same cadence, same visibility. A log that appears only when the strategy makes money is not disclosing anything – it is publishing selectively, and selectivity is the opposite of a record.

    How to read one

    Start at the bottom. Look for the entries you would least want to write about yourself: the closed-out losers, the reversals, the votes that went the other way. How they are treated tells you how the rest of the document was treated.

    Then check the timestamps against the market. Pull a dated entry and compare it to the price on that date. If the log consistently looks prescient, either the strategy is remarkable or the dating is loose. The market will tell you which.

    Then count the gaps. A log with quiet weeks is a log that stopped being kept, or a log that was cleaned. Both are informative.

    Why the schedule matters as much as the content

    A log is only as credible as its publishing rhythm. Win or lose, entry or no entry, the record runs on the same calendar. That constraint is what makes it auditable.

    A track record assembled after the fact – wins highlighted, losses folded into a footnote – cannot be checked, because you never know what was left out. A log that runs on schedule can be checked, because the omissions would be visible as blank slots. Consistency of schedule is not a formatting preference. It is the mechanism that makes the document trustworthy.

    What to ask before you trust a strategy

    Five questions, in this order:

    1. Can I see the log, not just the summary?
    2. Does every entry carry an as-of date?
    3. Is the dissent published, or only the consensus?
    4. Are the losses there, on the same schedule as the wins?
    5. What is missing, and who decided it was missing?

    A strategy that answers all five is giving you something you can verify. A strategy that answers four is giving you something you can mostly verify. A strategy that answers two is giving you a narrative, and narratives are cheap.

    You do not need to agree with a single decision in the log to trust the process behind it. You need to be able to see the decisions, dated, held to the same standard whether they worked or not. That is the standard the log exists to meet.

    The public log of every vote, dissent and fill is free to read. The membership adds the logged-in view: current positions, the full decision history, and the cross-account picture across everything the committee runs.

    This article is general information about how to read a decision log. It is not investment advice, it does not recommend any security, and past decisions are not a guide to future results. Read a log as evidence of process, not as a forecast.

  • How to Evaluate an Investment Strategy Before You Trust It

    How to Evaluate an Investment Strategy Before You Trust It

    Most investment strategies are built to be believed. Very few are built to be checked. That difference is the only one that matters to a reader who has already learned the hard way that a confident track record and a verifiable one are not the same object.

    This is a working audit. It is not a list of questions to make you feel diligent. Each step points at an artifact you can actually open, read, and date – a logged entry, a published fill, a ruled column. If a strategy cannot produce the artifact, that is your answer. You do not need to disprove it. You only need to notice that nothing was there to check.

    Step 1: Ask for the decision log, not the highlight reel

    Start with the log. A decision log is the dated record of what was decided, when, and on what basis – every vote, every dissent, every executed order, written down as it happened rather than reconstructed after the fact.

    What to demand:

    • A timestamp on each entry, not just a month and a year.
    • The reasoning recorded at the moment of the decision, not a later explanation fitted to the outcome.
    • The full record, including the decisions that went badly.

    A highlight reel tells you what a strategy wants you to feel. A log tells you how it thinks. If someone can show you profits but not decisions, you are not looking at a process. You are looking at a result, and results are the one thing that can be manufactured without a method.

    Step 2: Demand losses on the same schedule as wins

    This is the test most products fail. Ask how losses are published. Not whether they are disclosed somewhere, eventually, in a footnote – how they are published, and on what cadence.

    Wins and losses should travel the same road. If a strategy posts every gain within the hour and mentions drawdowns only in a quarterly letter, the schedule is the message. A drawdown is not an embarrassment to be managed; it is a number your decision depends on, and it should carry the same as-of date as everything else.

    A record that publishes losses on the same schedule as wins is telling you something structural: the people running it expect to be judged on the whole account, not the flattering rows of it.

    Step 3: Check the as-of dates

    Every number has a moment. A track record without an as-of date is a rumor with a percentage sign attached.

    For any figure you are shown, ask three things: as of when, measured how, and updated how often. “Up 12% since inception” means nothing without the date the pencil stopped. A strategy that commits to as-of dating on its own numbers is different from one that lets the reader assume the most flattering interpretation. One is designed to be audited. The other is designed to be skimmed.

    Hold the same standard for the small numbers as the big ones. If the headline is dated and the position table is not, the position table is decoration.

    Step 4: Find the dissent

    Consensus is cheap. Anyone can agree in public and decide in private. What you want to see is disagreement recorded next to the decision it belongs to.

    Ask whether the record shows dissent – a member who argued the other side, the reasons they gave, and what the committee did anyway. A process that logs its own disagreements is doing something no marketing page can fake: it is showing you its reasoning under pressure, before the outcome was known.

    Where there is no dissent anywhere in the record, there are two possibilities. Either everyone always agrees, which should worry you, or the dissent was real and went unwritten, which should worry you more.

    Step 5: Separate decision inputs from decoration

    Most strategies are full of numbers. Few distinguish the ones that drive a decision from the ones that dress a page.

    Decision inputs are the figures a position was actually changed by: the entry price, the size, the trigger, the exit, the fill. Decoration is everything designed to be looked at rather than acted on – smoothed equity curves with no drawdown shown, winning percentages with no position sizes, benchmarks chosen after the fact.

    Test each number the same way. Ask what decision it would change. If the answer is none, it is decoration, and its job is to make the process feel more rigorous than it is.

    Step 6: Trace one fill end to end

    Pick a single trade the strategy claims and try to follow it the whole way: the entry in the log, the reasoning behind it, the size, the execution, the exit. Can you walk from the decision to the fill to the result without a gap?

    If you can trace one position from vote to outcome, you understand how the whole thing works. If you cannot, ask why – because a verifiable process does not have unverifiable trades. A published fill is the receipt. Everything else is an invoice you wrote to yourself.

    What a real record looks like

    Put the six steps together and a shape appears. A strategy worth trusting publishes a dated decision log, runs losses and wins on the same schedule, stamps as-of dates on its own numbers, records its dissent, keeps its decision inputs separate from its decoration, and lets you trace a fill from entry to exit.

    That is a lot to ask. That is the point.

    None of this guarantees a strategy will make money. Nothing does, and anyone who says otherwise is selling something other than a process. What the audit gives you is narrower and more useful: a way to tell whether the thing in front of you is a method you can examine or a story you are being asked to accept. The first can be followed with your eyes open. The second has to be trusted on faith, and faith is not a position you can size.

    Start with the log. If there is no log, stop there.

    This article is general information about how to evaluate an investment process, not investment advice. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Diers Capital publishes its public decision log, including losses and dissent, on the same schedule as its wins; past performance does not predict future results, and you should consider your own circumstances or seek independent advice before acting.

  • What Is a Trading Decision Log? A Plain Definition, Field by Field

    What Is a Trading Decision Log? A Plain Definition, Field by Field

    What Is a Trading Decision Log? A Plain Definition, Field by Field

    A trading decision log is a dated record of what you decided before you placed a trade, and why.

    That is the whole definition. Everything after it is bookkeeping.

    The word doing the work is before. A log written after the position is open is not a decision log. It is a story about a decision, and stories get edited once the outcome is known. A log written before the fill commits you to a position in your own words, at a fixed date, with no knowledge of how it ends.

    This is why a log can be audited and a diary cannot.

    What a decision log is not

    It is not a trade journal. A journal usually records what happened – entries, exits, profit and loss – and often gets written in a single sitting at month end.

    It is not a watchlist. A watchlist says what you might buy. A log says what you decided to buy, at what size, against what evidence, and what would prove you wrong.

    It is not a performance claim. A log says nothing about whether the decision was good. It only fixes the decision in time so that later, someone other than you can check it.

    The fields, one by one

    A useful log is narrow. Add fields and you stop filling it in. These are the ones that survive contact with a real process.

    As-of date. The timestamp the entry is written. Not the trade date. The as-of date is the promise that nothing in the entry was known after that moment.

    Instrument and direction. What was bought or sold, long or short.

    Size. How much, and how that size relates to the rest of the book. A position with no stated size cannot be reconciled against anything.

    Thesis. One or two sentences on why. If it takes a paragraph, it is not a thesis yet.

    Evidence. What you actually read – a filing, a dataset, a methodology page. Name it. “It felt cheap” is a mood, not evidence.

    Invalidation. The condition that would prove the decision wrong. This is the field most people skip, and it is the one that makes the rest checkable. A decision with no defined invalidation can never be marked wrong, which means it can never be marked right either.

    Expected holding period. Weeks, months, years. A thesis with no horizon cannot be judged on schedule.

    The vote or the reason. If one person decides, say so. If a committee decides, record the decision and any dissent. A log that hides dissent is a log that has been cleaned up.

    Executed or not. A decision can be logged and then not taken. Recording the pass is as useful as recording the fill – it is the only way to see what you talked yourself out of.

    Why the as-of date carries the weight

    The as-of date is the one field that cannot be reconstructed later. Everything else can be rebuilt from memory, roughly, with the benefit of hindsight.

    Fix the date and a strange thing happens: the entry stops being a record of what you believe now and becomes a record of what you believed then. Those are different documents, and only one of them can be graded.

    The convention worth adopting is blunt: every number in the entry carries an as-of date, and no entry is ever revised after the fact. Corrections are added as new entries, dated, so the trail of thinking stays visible.

    How to reconcile a logged entry against the fill

    This is the step that turns a log into a control.

    After the fill, place the two documents side by side: the entry you wrote before the trade, and the confirmation that followed it. Then answer three questions.

    1. Does the fill match the decision? Same instrument, same direction, same size band.
    2. Did the invalidation you named get touched at any point – and if so, did you act on it?
    3. Was the entry written before the fill? The dates settle it.

    A log you never reconcile is a filing cabinet. A log you reconcile on a schedule is a feedback loop, and it is the only version that tells you anything about the process rather than the outcome.

    One more discipline: publish the misses on the same schedule as the wins. An audit trail that only runs when the news is good is not an audit trail – it is a highlight reel with dates on it.

    What a log lets a reader check

    For someone evaluating a strategy, the log is the difference between a claim and a record. A track record without a log asks you to trust the summary. A log lets you test the summary.

    You can look for entries dated before fills. You can look for the losing decisions sitting next to the winning ones, on the same page, with the same formatting. You can look for invalidation rules that were actually observed. And you can look for the decisions that were never taken.

    None of that requires believing anyone. It requires a document with dates on it.

    Diers Capital’s public log of every vote, dissent and fill stays free to read – no account, no paywall. The committee records decisions before the fill, dates every figure, and publishes losses on the same schedule as wins. Membership adds the logged-in view on top: current positions, full decision history and the cross-account picture. The log itself is the part we would rather you verified.

    The short version

    A trading decision log is a dated, pre-trade record of what you decided and why, with a stated invalidation and a size, kept in a form where it can later be checked against the fill that followed. Write it before the trade. Date what you know. Never edit it after. Reconcile it on schedule.

    Then the log stops describing your decisions and starts testing them.

    This article is educational and describes a method, not investment advice. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Figures referenced in any Diers Capital log are published with their own as-of dates and can change.

  • What One Quarter of Published Votes and Fills Shows That a Track Record Summary Doesn’t

    What One Quarter of Published Votes and Fills Shows That a Track Record Summary Doesn’t

    A track record summary is a conclusion. A published log is a document. They can describe the same quarter and still tell you different things, because a summary is assembled after the fact by the party being judged, and a log is assembled while the decision is still expensive.

    This is a walk through one quarter of a published record, read the way you would read it if you were deciding whether to trust it. Not the highlights. The structure: which votes carried dissent, how losses sit on the publishing schedule next to wins, and where a summary would have quietly dropped the inconvenient entries.

    Why a summary and a record are different documents

    A summary answers one question: did it work? A record answers a harder one: how would I know?

    Summaries are built backwards. You start with the result you want to present, then choose the window, the benchmark, the starting date and the positions that flatter it. None of that requires dishonesty. It only requires selection, and selection leaves no trace.

    A record is built forwards. Each entry is written before the outcome is known, dated, and attributed. That matters because the only cheap way to fake a forward record is to stop publishing the entries you would rather not explain – which is exactly what a published, complete log makes visible.

    Reading the quarter the way an auditor would

    Start with the votes, not the returns

    The first thing to read in a committee record is not performance. It is the decision trail: what was put to a vote, when, and what the committee decided. Returns are an output. The votes are the process, and the process is the part you can check.

    In a quarter of this log you see the shape of a working committee rather than a single voice. Proposals get tabled, tabled items get deferred, and some ideas never reach a position at all. A summary usually compresses all of that into a percentage. The percentage is not wrong. It is just silent about everything that produced it.

    Find the dissents

    Look for where the record disagrees with itself. A logged committee publishes dissents: the vote that went against the majority, the member who wanted a smaller size, the objection that was overruled and recorded anyway.

    This is the first real test of track record transparency. A record with no dissent is not a record of a committee. It is a record of a decision that was announced to a committee. If every entry reads the same way, you are reading a press release with dates on it.

    Dissents are also the most useful entries to audit against later outcomes. When a position goes wrong, the dissent tells you whether the error was in the thesis or in the sizing, and whether anyone inside the process saw it coming.

    Check the publishing schedule, not the outcome

    Then look at the dates. Not the returns – the publication dates.

    A record that publishes wins promptly and losses after a delay is not a track record. It is an announcement schedule. The sequencing is the entire claim: if the bad entries arrive late, or arrive only once they have been reframed as “lessons”, the reader is never seeing the decision in the conditions it was actually made.

    The standard to demand is dull and structural: every entry published on the same schedule regardless of whether it helped or hurt. Wins on the same footing as losses, same format, same as-of date. That is what publishing investment losses actually means in practice – not a confession page, just the same ruled column applied without exception.

    Where a summary drops the inconvenient entries

    Now go back to the summary and see what it left out.

    The positions that were closed at a loss and never mentioned again. The idea that was tabled three times and quietly retired. The month where the committee’s sizing was wrong and the record shows it. The drawdown that a reader inside the strategy felt in real time and the summary presents as a flat line between two good quarters.

    This is the substance of investing strategy drawdown disclosure. Drawdown is not a footnote to the record; it is the part of the record that tells you what holding the strategy would have felt like. Any summary that reports returns without the shape of the losses has removed the only information a reader actually needs to decide whether they could stay in.

    What to demand before you trust any record

    If you are auditing a strategy, a newsletter, or a fund, ask for the same four things in the same order.

    1. The entries, not the summary. A dated log of decisions made before outcomes were known.
    2. The dissent. Evidence that more than one view existed and that disagreement was recorded rather than edited out.
    3. The losing entries, on the same schedule as the winning ones. If losses are published late or in a different format, the schedule is the story.
    4. The as-of date. Every number should carry the date it was true. A figure without an as-of date is decoration.

    A process that can produce those four things can be audited. A process that cannot is asking you to trust a conclusion you have no way to check. This is the difference between process and stock tips, and it is not a matter of degree – it is a difference in what the reader is permitted to see.

    You can read a version of this against your own criteria: pick the last quarter, look for the losses, and see whether they appear on the same schedule as the wins.

    The public log, and the member view

    The public log of every vote, dissent and fill stays free, and it always will. That is the part that has to be checkable by anyone who wants to check it, otherwise the word “transparency” is doing no work.

    The Diers Capital Membership adds the logged-in view on top: current positions, the full decisions history, and the cross-account picture. It is the difference between reading a quarter as a document and watching the next one being written.

    Nothing here is investment advice, and nothing here is a projection. It is a description of what a record contains, what a summary tends to leave out, and what you should ask for before you take anyone’s numbers on faith.

  • Why a Track Record Without Published Losses Isn’t a Track Record

    Why a Track Record Without Published Losses Isn’t a Track Record

    Why a Track Record Without Published Losses Isn’t a Track Record

    A track record is a ledger. A ledger has two sides, and a ruled column is only honest when every entry lands in it, not just the ones you would rather show.

    Most performance pages are not ledgers. They are showrooms. They begin on a good month, they end on a better one, and the space between is quiet. You cannot audit a showroom. You can only admire it.

    This is a direct answer to the question every cautious investor eventually asks: where are the losses? It sets out the standard we hold ourselves to, and the standard you should hold anyone to before you trust a strategy with your money.

    What actually counts as a track record?

    A track record is a dated, complete sequence of decisions and their outcomes – wins and losses alike – that a third party can check against the market’s own prices.

    That last part is the test. A number you cannot verify is a claim, not a record. A number presented with an as-of date, attached to a stated position, and consistent with the historical price on that date is evidence. The difference is not stylistic. It is the difference between a story and a source.

    So the first question is not “how good are the returns?” It is “what is the full sequence, and can I check it?”

    Why should losses be published on the same schedule as wins?

    Because a record’s value comes from its completeness, not its flattery. If wins are published weekly and losses appear only when someone remembers to mention them, the published record is a selection, and a selection tells you about the editor, not the method.

    The standard we favor is plain: the same schedule for both. Every fill, every vote, every dissent, logged at the time it happens. Losses on the same cadence as gains. No quiet months, no retroactive framing, no “the strategy adjusted” without a dated entry saying so.

    Investing track record transparency is not a marketing posture. It is an accounting one. You publish the whole column or you are not keeping a record at all.

    What is drawdown disclosure, and why does it matter?

    A drawdown is the distance between a peak and the lowest point that follows it. Drawdown disclosure is publishing that distance – how far the account fell, over what period, and what the committee did about it – rather than waiting for the recovery and describing it in the past tense.

    This matters because drawdown is where a method actually shows its character. Anyone can hold a position in a rising market. The questions that separate a process from a pitch are all asked in the decline: Did the sizing rules hold? Did the committee follow its own criteria or improvise? Was anything added to the position that wasn’t justified by the rulebook?

    Drawdown disclosure is the only way an outside reader can answer those questions for themselves. Without it, you are asked to take the recovery on faith and never see the season that tested the method.

    How do you tell a real record from a highlight reel?

    Read for the shape, not the peak.

    • Does it have dates? Every figure should carry an as-of date. A performance number without one is a mood, not a measurement.
    • Are the losses present? Look for the down months in the same table as the up months. If they are absent, ask why.
    • Are decisions and outcomes separated? A decision log records what was chosen and why, before the outcome is known. A results page records what happened, after the fact. You want to see both, and you want to see them timestamped.
    • Is dissent visible? A committee that never disagrees is not a committee. Published dissent – the vote that lost – is one of the strongest signals that the log is real.
    • Is the whole account shown, or one sleeve of it? A cross-account view shows the picture as it is, including the positions that went the wrong way.

    A highlight reel passes none of these. A ledger passes all of them.

    What should you look for before trusting an investment strategy?

    Ask for the artifacts, not the adjectives.

    Before you trust an investment strategy, look for a decision log with timestamps; a published record that includes losses on the same schedule as wins; drawdowns named, sized, and dated rather than alluded to; and a stated rulebook that the published decisions actually follow. Ask where the numbers come from and whether you can reconcile them against prices you can check yourself.

    If the answers are all narrative and none are artifacts, you have your answer. A strategy that cannot be audited is not a strategy you can evaluate – it is a strategy you can only believe or disbelieve, and belief is not a position sizing method.

    This is also why we keep the public log free. Every vote, every dissent, every fill, whether it flattered us or not. You should be able to read the record before you decide anything, and you should be able to read the losses in it without asking us for permission.

    The test is whether you can check it

    A track record without published losses is not modest. It is incomplete. And an incomplete record cannot be audited, only believed.

    So hold the standard high, and hold it to everyone equally. Ask where the losses are. Ask for the as-of date. Ask for the decision that preceded the outcome. When someone can hand you a dated, two-sided ledger – wins and drawdowns, entries and dissent, on the same schedule – you are no longer being sold a story. You are being shown a record you can check. That is the only kind worth trusting.

    The public log is free. Read it before you decide.

  • How to Evaluate an Investment Strategy Before You Trust It

    How to Evaluate an Investment Strategy Before You Trust It

    Any strategy can be described well. Very few can be checked. The difference between the two is the whole of this article.

    Evaluating an investment strategy is not a matter of reading a convincing pitch and deciding whether you believe it. Belief is the thing being sold to you. What you want instead is a method you can run yourself, on evidence the seller either publishes or does not. That method has five steps, and every step points at a real artifact – a log, a fill, a dated column – rather than an assertion.

    Here is how to evaluate an investment strategy before you trust it, and what to look for before you commit a single dollar.

    Start With the Record, Not the Pitch

    Skip the performance summary on the landing page. It is the most edited document a manager will ever show you. Go instead to the raw record and ask one question: can I see the reasoning behind each decision, in the order it was made?

    A pitch tells you what a strategy did. A record tells you why it did it, when it knew what, and what it gave up. Only the second one is auditable. If the record does not exist, the pitch is unfalsifiable – and an unfalsifiable claim is not evidence, it is marketing.

    Step 1: Demand the Decision Log

    Ask for the decision log. This is the first and most important artifact.

    A trading decision log is the dated account of every decision a strategy made: what was bought or sold, at what size, on what reasoning, and who disagreed. It is not a performance chart. It is the ruled column behind the chart – the entries that produced the number.

    What to check in it:

    • Is every entry dated, with the date the decision was made rather than the date it was published?
    • Does each entry state the reasoning at the time, not a rationale written afterward to fit the outcome?
    • Is dissent recorded? A committee that never disagrees is not a committee, it is a rubber stamp.
    • Are entries published on a fixed schedule, or only when they look good?

    If a strategy cannot show you a decision log, you cannot evaluate it. You can only take its word. That is a categorically weaker position, and you should price it accordingly.

    Step 2: Check Whether Losses Are Published on the Same Schedule as Wins

    This is the fastest filter that exists, and almost nothing survives it.

    Ask a simple question: when this strategy loses, do you hear about it on the same cadence you hear about the wins? Or does the losing position appear only after it has been quietly closed, while every winner is announced the day it is opened?

    Publishing investment losses on the same schedule as wins is the operational proof that a track record is complete. A record with only the wins in it is not a track record; it is a highlight reel. The math is unforgiving here. A strategy that hides its losers is not reporting a lower loss – it is misreporting its risk, and any number built on that record is decoration.

    Look for a drawdown column that sits next to the returns column, running the whole time. Look for the losing quarters published in the quarter they happened. If the disclosure only exists in the aggregate, and only after the fact, treat the headline number as unverified.

    Step 3: Date Every Number

    A number without a date is a rumor.

    Investing track record transparency lives or dies on as-of dates. Every figure a strategy shows you should carry the date it was true. “Up 40% since inception” means nothing without knowing when inception was and what happened between then and now. A return reported without its window, its benchmark, and its drawdown is not information.

    Demand the as-of date on:

    • performance figures
    • position sizing and current holdings
    • any cash or allocation percentage
    • any claim about “since we started”

    A manager who dates every number is telling you that the numbers can be checked. One who does not is telling you something too, if you are listening.

    Step 4: Separate Process From Stock Tips

    Process versus stock tips is the real fork in the road, and it is easy to spot once you know where to look.

    A tip tells you what to buy. A process tells you how the decision was reached, and lets you watch the same method run again on a different name. Tips are unfalsifiable because there is no method to test – only an outcome to hope for. Process is falsifiable, which is exactly why it is worth more.

    Here is the test. Ask the person or product to describe the method behind a past decision in enough detail that you could have predicted the next one. If they can, you are looking at a process. If the answer is “we just knew,” or “our intuition,” or a story told only after the fact, you are looking at a tip in a nicer suit.

    Quantitative investing methodology is simply process made explicit: rules stated in advance, applied consistently, and logged where you can see them. You do not need to run the math yourself to benefit from it. You only need the rules to have existed before the outcome.

    Step 5: Read the Disclosure as Part of the Method

    Treat the legal disclosure as a step in the audit, not fine print to scroll past.

    A serious strategy states its limitations plainly: what it does not do, what it cannot promise, what could go wrong, and who is responsible for what. That is not a hedge. It is the boundary of the claim, and without it the claim is unbounded – which is another way of saying unverified.

    Ask whether the disclosure is specific. “Past performance does not guarantee future results” on its own is boilerplate. A strategy that tells you where its method is weak, and dates its own numbers, has told you more about its honesty than any testimonial could.

    What to Look For Before Trusting an Investment Strategy

    Run the five steps as a checklist:

    1. Is there a decision log, dated and reasoned, published on a fixed schedule?
    2. Are losses published on the same schedule as wins, with drawdown shown beside returns?
    3. Does every number carry an as-of date, a window, and a benchmark?
    4. Is the method falsifiable – could you predict the next decision from the stated rules?
    5. Is the disclosure specific about limits, or is it boilerplate?

    A strategy that passes all five is not guaranteed to make money. Nothing is. But it is falsifiable, it is checkable, and it can be judged on evidence rather than on charm. That is the only honest standard there is.

    The point of the audit is not to find a strategy that never loses. It is to find one that shows you the losses, dates its numbers, and lets you watch the method run. You do not have to trust a pitch that survives all five. You only have to read the record. Trust the process that can be checked, and you will never again have to trust a person who cannot be.

  • How to Evaluate an Investment Strategy Before You Trust It With Money

    How to Evaluate an Investment Strategy Before You Trust It With Money

    How to Evaluate an Investment Strategy Before You Trust It With Money

    You cannot verify a forecast. You can verify a process.

    That is the whole point of evaluating a strategy before you fund it. Anyone can describe returns they intend to produce. Far fewer can show you the ruled columns behind them: what was decided, when, at what price, and what happened when the decision went wrong. The work below is a sequence of checks, not a personality test. Each step points at an artifact you can ask for and read.

    Read the sequence as of September 19, 2026. The method does not expire. The examples do.

    Start with the artifact, not the argument

    Before you evaluate a systematic investing process, decide what evidence you would accept. Not a narrative. Not a chart with the axes cropped. An artifact.

    Three artifacts carry most of the weight:

    • A decision log with dated entries
    • A published record that includes losses, on the same schedule as wins
    • A statement of method precise enough that a stranger could reproduce the rules

    If none of those exists, you are not evaluating a strategy. You are evaluating a pitch. Stop there and save yourself the month.

    Ask for the decision log

    A decision log – sometimes called a trading decision log – is the dated record of what the process decided and why. It is the difference between process versus stock tips in physical form.

    Ask for these four things in every entry:

    1. The date of the decision and the date it was acted on, kept separate
    2. The instrument, the direction, and the size
    3. The stated reason, in the words used at the time
    4. The fill: the price actually paid, and on which account

    A real log is boring. It has entries you would not have chosen to publish. It records the decision that was later reversed and says so on the same page.

    A retrospective summary – the kind assembled after the fact into a tidy table – is not a log. A log is written forward and dated forward. You can usually tell the difference within ten entries, because forward-written logs contain the small embarrassment of ordinary decision-making.

    Read the record on the same schedule as the wins

    This is the fastest filter available. Ask one question: when do you publish losses?

    If losses appear late, quietly, or inside a footnote, the rest of the record is decoration. Publishing investment losses on the same schedule as wins is not modesty. It is the mechanism that makes track record transparency possible. A record you can only see the good half of is not a record.

    Check three details while you are there:

    • As-of dates. Every figure should carry the date it was measured against – “as of September 19, 2026,” not “recently” or “since inception.”
    • Return basis. Net or gross, and after which costs. A record that never states its basis is not comparable to anything, including itself.
    • The losing column. Find the worst stretch and read what the process said while it was happening.

    If the losses are cancelled from the window entirely, treat the remainder of the numbers as unverified.

    Check whether dissent survives the meeting

    A single decision-maker with no published disagreement is not a committee. It is one opinion with better formatting.

    Look for dissent in the record. If a process is run by more than one person, the log should show disagreements, the arguments made, and how the vote resolved. Dissent that appears in the log is a signal that the record reflects what happened rather than what the writer would prefer you to believe.

    If every decision was unanimous, either the group is small and aligned to the point of redundancy, or the disagreement is being removed before publication. Both are worth knowing before you commit money.

    Test the numbers that carry information

    Most published statistics about a strategy are decoration. A small number carry information. Sort them accordingly.

    Carries information:

    • Drawdown disclosure. The depth and duration of the worst peak-to-trough decline, with the dates. An investing strategy drawdown disclosure tells you what the ride actually felt like.
    • Number of decisions, not just outcomes. Twenty decisions with three winners and seventeen losers is a different animal from three decisions with three winners, even if the final return matches.
    • Fills versus signals. The gap between the price the process identified and the price it actually transacted at. Wide gaps mean the backtest was better than the portfolio.
    • Account-level detail. If the same process runs across several accounts, the differences between them are information about execution, not noise.

    Decoration:

    • Total return quoted without a benchmark or a basis
    • Win rate with no average size of win and loss
    • Anything measured from a date chosen because it flatters the curve

    A quantitative investing methodology that cannot survive this sort is still a method. It is just not one you can check.

    Soundings before you commit

    Run this list against any strategy you are seriously considering. Take a sounding at each line; write the answer down.

    • What is the exact rule you would follow, stated so a stranger could run it?
    • How many decisions has the process actually made, and over what window?
    • What is the worst drawdown, with dates?
    • What does the process publish, and on what schedule?
    • Where are the losses in that publication?
    • Who disagreed, and how was it recorded?
    • What does the fee come out of, and what is the return basis?
    • What would have to be true for you to conclude the process is broken?

    The last question matters most. A process with no stated failure condition cannot be falsified, and a strategy that cannot be falsified cannot be evaluated – only believed.

    When the process fails your audit

    Failing the audit is common, and it is not always fatal. Distinguish between three outcomes.

    • Missing artifacts. The process may be real but undocumented. Ask again in writing; if the answer stays vague, the answer is no.
    • Present artifacts, weak disclosure. The log exists but the losses are thin. You can still proceed, at a smaller size, while you watch whether the losing column fills in.
    • No artifacts, strong claims. Walk away. No amount of confidence substitutes for a record.

    The cost of an audit is a few hours. The cost of skipping one is measured in years.

    The point of the exercise

    You are not trying to predict what a strategy will return. You are deciding whether the process is the kind of thing that can be checked at all. If it can, you will be able to tell – later, when it matters – whether it is working or broken.

    That is a modest thing to ask for. It is also the only thing you can verify before the money moves.

    Start with the log. Read the losing column first. Everything else is commentary.

  • What Is a Trading Decision Log, and Why Every Vote Should Be Dated

    What Is a Trading Decision Log, and Why Every Vote Should Be Dated

    What Is a Trading Decision Log, and Why Every Vote Should Be Dated

    A trading decision log is the dated record of what a strategy’s decision-makers actually decided, when they decided it, and how each decision was made – including the votes that lost. It is not a journal of feelings and it is not a highlight reel. It is a ledger. Its purpose is to make a process checkable by someone who was not in the room.

    You probably already know how to read a filing. Read a decision log the same way: for what it states, what it omits, and the date stamped on every line.

    What a trading decision log records

    Ask ten people what a decision log contains and you will get ten answers. Here is the working definition this brand uses, and it is narrow on purpose.

    A decision log records, per entry:

    • The instrument and the action considered.
    • The vote – how many in favor, how many against.
    • The dissent, attributed and argued, not summarized away.
    • The size and the fill, when a decision turns into an order.
    • The as-of date: the moment the decision was made, not the moment it was published.

    That last line is the one most people miss. A log without dates is a story. A log with dates is evidence.

    Why dissent belongs in the log

    Most published track records are written by the winner. A position that worked gets an entry. A position that failed quietly disappears, or gets folded into a later success with a sentence like “we adjusted.”

    That is not a log. That is a narrative with a good editor.

    A decision log keeps the losing votes because they are the part you can learn from and the part that proves the process is real. If a committee never records disagreement, you are not reading a process. You are reading a press release. The dissent is where the method shows itself – what was argued, what the downside case was, and why the majority went the other way anyway.

    Dissent also gives you something to measure. A strategy that records its minority views and later checks whether they were right is doing something a tip sheet cannot: it is building a file on its own judgment.

    Why every vote should be dated

    Dates do three jobs, and none of them is decoration.

    First, an as-of date fixes a claim in time. “We were long before the move” is worthless. “We entered on the ninth, filled at the open on the tenth, and here is the log entry dated that morning” is a claim you can verify against the tape.

    Second, dates expose the tell. A track record published all at once, with no dates attached to the individual decisions, is almost always assembled after the fact. When you cannot see when each call was made, you cannot tell foresight from hindsight. The dates are the only thing standing between a track record and a rewrite.

    Third, dates make losses schedulable. If wins are dated and losses are not, the record is not a record – it is selection. The point of dating every vote is that losses get published on the same schedule as wins, in the same format, with the same discipline. If the cadence breaks when the news is bad, you have your answer about the operator.

    What a decision log is not

    It is worth stating the negative, because the term is used loosely.

    A decision log is not a watchlist. A watchlist is a set of ideas; a log is a set of commitments with dates and votes attached.

    A decision log is not a P&L statement. The P&L tells you what happened to the money. The log tells you what was decided and why, which is how you judge whether the next decision will be any good.

    A decision log is not a marketing document. The moment a log is written for an audience rather than for the record, it stops being evidence. You can tell the difference by looking for the entries that make the author look bad. If there are none, you are not reading a log.

    How to read a decision log you did not write

    Here is a short list you can apply to any published record, ours included.

    1. Look for a date on every entry. Undated decisions are unverifiable decisions.
    2. Look for a losing vote. A record with no dissent is a record with no process.
    3. Look for losses on the same cadence as wins. Same format, same schedule, no quiet months.
    4. Look for the fill, not just the call. A decision that never became an order is an opinion.
    5. Look for what is missing. The gaps in a record are as informative as the entries.

    None of this requires special access. It requires only that the operator published enough to be checked – and that you take the time to check it.

    The public log at Diers Capital

    Diers Capital keeps a public log of every vote, dissent and fill, dated as of the day the decision was made. It stays free to read whether or not you are a member. The membership adds the logged-in view on top: current positions, the full decisions history, and the cross-account picture.

    We publish the losses on the same schedule as the wins, because a log with the losses removed is not a log. You can read the process and decide for yourself whether it holds up.

    Nothing here is investment advice, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy or sell any security. A decision log is a record of what was decided, not a promise about what happens next. Past decisions, published or otherwise, do not tell you what future returns will be.

    The useful question is not whether a strategy made money last quarter. It is whether you can see how it decided, when it decided, and what it admitted when it was wrong. A dated log is the only way to answer that.

  • False Depth: How to Audit a SaaS Revenue Multiple Before the Hull Hits Structural Reality

    False Depth: How to Audit a SaaS Revenue Multiple Before the Hull Hits Structural Reality

    A revenue multiple is a sounding line. Drop it over the side and it returns a number: so many times forward revenue, so many turns of EV to ARR. The number looks like a measurement of depth. Often it is a measurement of how the line was weighted.

    False depth is the failure mode. The chart reads calm, the multiple reads reasonable, and the hull is still closing on a reef that the same numbers, read correctly, would have shown months earlier. This is an audit of that failure – not a forecast of any company’s fate, but a sequence of checks you can run against a filing before you trust the depth it reports.

    Step 1: Establish what the revenue actually is

    Start with the top line and refuse the label. “Revenue” on a SaaS income statement is frequently a blend of recurring subscription and one-time, low-quality line items: professional services, implementation, training, hardware. Those dollars bill once and leave. They carry the same weight in the multiple as a subscription dollar and none of the same durability.

    Pull the revenue disaggregation note. If subscription and services are not separated, that absence is itself a finding. A company that reports a single blended revenue figure is asking you to price its recurring base at the rate its most repeatable dollars deserve. You cannot audit a multiple you cannot decompose.

    Step 2: Test whether it recurs

    Recurring revenue is a claim about the future, and the only honest test of it is retention. Look for two numbers: gross revenue retention and net revenue retention.

    Gross retention tells you how much of last year’s base simply stayed. If it sits in the low 90s or below, a meaningful slice of the base churns every year, and growth has to run hard just to stand still. Net retention, which includes expansion, hides that churn work behind upsells. A headline net retention of 115% built on 88% gross retention is a different business from the same net figure built on 96% gross. Same sounding. Different seabed.

    If the company does not disclose retention, or discloses only net, treat the depth as unverified.

    Step 3: Check what survives to cash

    Recurring revenue that never converts to cash is a claim, not a position. Move down the statement and follow the dollars.

    Two checks matter most. First, gross margin adjusted for stock-based compensation: if the software margin looks like 80% but only after excluding a large non-cash expense, restate it and see what is left. Second, the burn multiple – net cash burned per dollar of net new recurring revenue added. A burn multiple above 3 means the company is spending more than three dollars of cash to buy one dollar of new recurring revenue. That is not scaling; that is buying soundings with the equipment fund.

    A high multiple on revenue that consumes cash to exist is false depth read as growth.

    Step 4: Check concentration and duration

    Depth is not uniform across a reef. Neither is revenue.

    Read the concentration disclosure. If a single customer or a small handful of contracts make up a material share of the base, the multiple is priced on a base that can leave in one renewal cycle. Then read contract duration: multi-year, annual, monthly. A base of monthly contracts priced at the same multiple as a base of three-year commitments is mispriced, whatever the headline growth rate says.

    Step 5: Date the sounding

    Every number you have gathered is as-of a date, and the date matters as much as the number. A multiple on ARR as of the last quarter-end is stale the moment the quarter that follows disagrees.

    Look for the as-of stamp on each figure: revenue, retention, cash. Where a company presents a trailing-twelve-month figure beside a current-quarter narrative, reconcile them. The gap between the two is where false depth usually hides – the narrative is current, the metric is old, and the multiple is priced on the fresher-sounding of the two.

    Step 6: Compare the rate of change, not just the level

    Two companies can carry the same multiple and be nothing alike, because the multiple is a level and the risk lives in the slope. A base growing 40% at 90% gross retention is converting soundings into chart. The same base at the same multiple, decelerating from 60% to 20% with retention drifting down a point a quarter, is a hull that has already touched and is waiting for the keel to announce it.

    Pull three or four periods of the same metric and read the direction and the second derivative. Deceleration under a flat multiple is the single most reliable warning that the depth reading was wrong.

    Why false depth reads as depth

    None of these checks is exotic. The reason a false sounding passes is structural. Multiples are quoted as a single number, and a single number is easy to price, easy to compare, and easy to repeat. The audit is a sequence of smaller numbers that disagree with each other, and disagreement is uncomfortable to hold in one glance. So the market holds the glance and drops the sequence.

    The reef does not care which was easier.

    What an auditable process does about it

    A process you can trust does not escape false depth by being smarter than the market on any given name. It escapes it by refusing to price a multiple it has not decomposed, and by publishing the soundings that came back shallow on the same schedule as the ones that came back deep.

    That second part is the one most strategies leave out. It is easy to publish a method that has only ever been applied to winners. A log that carries the bad soundings next to the good ones, each stamped with the date it was taken, is verifiable in a way a narrative is not. You can check it. You can disagree with it. You cannot be quietly told a different story later.

    The short version

    Before you trust a SaaS revenue multiple, decompose the revenue, test the retention, follow the dollars to cash, size the concentration, check the contract duration, date every figure, and read the slope rather than the level. Where a company – or a strategy – will not show you those soundings, the depth is not deep. It is unmeasured, which is the most dangerous reading of all.

    Nothing here is a recommendation to buy or sell any security, and no figure in this piece should be taken as a current quote for any company. It is a method for reading numbers that are already public, applied on the same schedule to the ones that flatter and the ones that do not.